blog

Red flags a suspiciously low siding bid is hiding

Siding bid red flags every Minnesota HOA board should catch — missing tear-off, no rot allowance, vague flashing, no WRB spec, lump-sum-only quotes, and more.

Request a siding review

What Minnesota code actually requires

Several of these red flags trace back to the same source: Minnesota’s re-siding requirements. Code requires a continuous water-resistive barrier behind the cladding and corrosion-resistant flashing applied shingle-fashion, and kick-out flashing must be installed when re-siding existing buildings. Building departments inspect the WRB and flashing before new siding goes on, check sheathing repair mid-project, and sign off on the finished work. A bid that stays vague on any of these isn’t just thin — it’s quoting work that can’t pass inspection as written. (See do you need a permit to re-side in Minneapolis.) (MN DLI re-siding fact sheet)

How to make a low bid prove itself

You don’t have to reject a low number. You have to make it earn the price.

  1. Issue one written scope so every contractor quotes the same project.
  2. Require line-item pricing and reject lump-sum-only quotes.
  3. Confirm the code items by name — WRB product, flashing type, kick-out, inspections.
  4. Pin down how hidden rot is priced before signing, not after.
  5. Compare line by line. If the cheap bid is still cheap once the scopes match, it earned it.

When you run a low bid through these steps, one of two things happens: it holds up and you’ve found a deal, or the missing line items surface and you’ve dodged a change-order trap.

FAQ

What’s the biggest red flag in a low siding bid? A missing tear-off line. If the bid doesn’t specify removing the existing siding, it likely plans to cover over it — skipping disposal, sheathing inspection, and trapping moisture behind the wall.

Why should I be wary of a lump-sum siding quote? A single number can’t be compared against other bids item by item, and it lets a contractor omit or hide entire categories of work. Line-item pricing makes the scope and the gaps visible.

Is a low bid always a bad sign? No. A low bid can be legitimate if it covers the same scope as the others. The danger is a low bid that’s cheap because it left work out. Match the scopes before judging the price.

What does Minnesota code require that a cheap bid might skip? A continuous water-resistive barrier, corrosion-resistant shingle-fashion flashing, and kick-out flashing on re-sides — all inspected before new siding goes up. Vague language on any of these is a warning sign.

What’s a rot-repair allowance and why does its absence matter? It’s a named dollar amount or unit price set aside for sheathing and framing damage found after tear-off. Without it, any rot becomes an open-ended change order priced on the contractor’s terms.


Related reading: What a real siding bid must include · Do you need a permit to re-side in Minneapolis? · What’s behind your siding: WRB and flashing